Introduction
Mikel Arteta’s 200th Premier League game as Arsenal manager was meant to be a milestone to celebrate, but instead, it turned into a brutal reminder of the club’s recurring struggles. Arsenal, once again, have fallen short in their bid for the Premier League title, leaving fans frustrated and questioning what went wrong.
Despite showing moments of brilliance, the Gunners have been unable to sustain their challenge against an unstoppable Manchester City side. While Arteta has transformed the Gunners into a competitive force, the familiar issues that derailed their 2022-23 campaign have resurfaced.
In this deep dive, we explore five key reasons why Arsenal’s Premier League title challenge collapsed once again.
1. Inconsistent Performances in Crucial Games
Arsenal’s inability to maintain consistency in high-pressure matches has been a major setback. Throughout the season, the team delivered dominant performances but faltered when it mattered most.
- Losses against mid-table teams such as Aston Villa and Fulham highlighted their struggles to grind out results in difficult fixtures.
- A disappointing defeat to Manchester City in a title-deciding game further proved the Gunners inability to win crucial six-pointers.
Unlike City and Liverpool, who thrive under pressure, the Gunners squad has repeatedly failed to show resilience in decisive moments, costing them vital points in the title race.
2. Lack of Squad Depth Compared to Rivals
While Arsenal have improved their squad significantly under Arteta, they still lack the squad depth necessary to compete on multiple fronts. Injuries to key players have exposed this weakness.
- Thomas Partey’s prolonged absence left the midfield lacking stability, forcing Arteta to over-rely on Jorginho and Declan Rice.
- Gabriel Jesus and Eddie Nketiah’s inconsistent form meant the Gunners struggled for goals when their wingers were out of form.
- In contrast, Manchester City boast world-class replacements for every position, ensuring they maintain momentum even during injury crises.
Without a fully equipped squad, the Gunners found themselves running out of steam in the latter part of the season, allowing their title rivals to surge ahead.
3. Poor Game Management and Tactical Decisions
While Arteta has evolved tactically over the years, some of his in-game management decisions have raised eyebrows. Arsenal have often found themselves unable to hold onto leads or respond effectively to tactical shifts from opponents.
- Late collapses against teams like Liverpool and Chelsea highlighted defensive vulnerabilities when under pressure.
- Substitutions have often come too late or failed to impact the game significantly, allowing the opposition to capitalize.
- Over-reliance on specific tactical patterns has made the Gunners predictable in certain matches, making it easier for well-organized teams to counter them.
A title-winning team requires adaptability, and the Gunners inability to switch tactics when needed has cost them valuable points.
4. Lack of a Clinical Goal-Scorer
Despite possessing a talented squad, the Gunners lack a true world-class finisher. Their failure to sign a prolific goal-scorer in the last two transfer windows has come back to haunt them.
- Gabriel Jesus, while a fantastic player, is not a 25-goal-a-season striker. His finishing has been inconsistent, and injuries have further limited his impact.
- Bukayo Saka and Gabriel Martinelli have carried much of the attacking burden, but when they are marked out of the game, Arsenal struggle to create chances.
- In comparison, Erling Haaland at Manchester City and Mohamed Salah at Liverpool have consistently delivered crucial goals, making the difference in the title race.
A lack of firepower up front has left Arsenal dropping points in winnable matches, ultimately costing them a shot at the title.
5. Mental Fragility in the Final Stretch of the Season
One of the most frustrating aspects of Arsenal’s recent title challenges has been their tendency to crumble under pressure in the final months of the campaign. This psychological weakness was evident last season and has resurfaced again.
- In 2023, Arsenal led the league for 248 days before collapsing in the final weeks. A similar scenario unfolded this season, with the team struggling to maintain momentum.
- Losses and draws in crucial games have seen them drop from top contenders to playing catch-up.
- The weight of expectation seems to get to the players, as seen in nervy performances against weaker opponents.
To win the Premier League, mental strength is just as crucial as technical ability. Arsenal must develop the resilience required to stay competitive until the final whistle of the season.
What Next for Arsenal?
Despite another disappointing title challenge, Arsenal are not far from becoming genuine contenders. Arteta has built a solid foundation, and with the right investments, the club could finally end their long wait for a Premier League trophy.
Key Areas to Improve Before Next Season:
✅ Sign a proven goal-scorer – A striker capable of scoring 25+ goals a season is a must.
✅ Strengthen squad depth – Reinforcements in midfield and defense will help sustain performance levels.
✅ Improve mentality in high-pressure situations – The squad needs leaders who can step up when the pressure is on.
✅ Tactical flexibility – Arteta must learn from Guardiola and Klopp, adapting tactics when necessary.
If Arsenal can address these issues, they will stand a much better chance of finally lifting the Premier League title in the coming seasons.
Final Thoughts
Arsenal’s 2024-25 campaign was another tale of what could have been. Mikel Arteta has transformed the club, but until they overcome their mental and tactical shortcomings, they will continue to fall short in the Premier League title race.
SUGGESTED FOR YOU
Shocking Premier League Weekend Results: 7 Biggest Talking Points
With the right signings and adjustments, Arsenal have the potential to go all the way. But for now, Gunners fans must endure yet another season of ‘almost’—a painful reality that has become all too familiar.
Did Arsenal Miss Their Best Chance?
Do you think Arsenal will finally win the Premier League next season? What changes do they need to make? Share your thoughts in the comments below!
